Then-National
Security Adviser Michael Flynn told FBI agents at the White House on
January 24, 2017 "not really" when asked if he had sought to convince
Russian ambassador not to escalate a brewing fight with the U.S.
over sanctions imposed by the Obama administration, according to an
explosive
new FD-302 witness report released just hours before Flynn is set to be sentenced.
Flynn
issued other apparently equivocal responses to FBI agents' questions,
and at various points suggested that such conversations might have
happened or that he could not recall them if they did, according to the
302.
The heavily redacted document
contained few definitive statements from Flynn, who later pleaded
guilty to making false statements about his contacts with Russia's
ambassador, in connection with the White House meeting.
Flynn was not charged with wrongdoing as a result of the substance of his calls with the Russian ambassador -- and a
Washington Post article published one day before his White House interview
with the agents, citing FBI sources, publicly revealed that the FBI had
wiretapped Flynn's calls and cleared him of any criminal conduct.
ANTI-TRUMP FBI AGENT PETER STRZOK, WHO INTERVIEWED FLYNN, HAD 'MEDIA LEAK STRATEGY'
The 302
indicates that Flynn was apparently aware his communications had been
monitored, and at several points he thanks the FBI agents for reminding
him of some of his conversations with Russian officials.
Separately, a
newly unsealed indictment
Monday revealed that two Flynn associates had been charged with
illegally lobbying for Turkey without properly registering under the
Foreign Agent Registration Act (FARA), and Mueller has claimed Flynn
also lied about his lobbying projects there. Flynn's guilty plea and
cooperation with the Mueller probe helped him avoid similar FARA-related charges, legal analysts have said.
The
newly released 302 was finalized on Feb. 15, 2017 after it was reviewed
by top FBI brass, just two days following Flynn's resignation after he
misled Vice President Pence about his communications with then-Russian
ambassador Sergey Kislyak.
The document stated that Flynn told
agents "not really" and "I don't remember" when they asked if he had
requested Kislyak and the Russians not engage in a "tit-for-tat" with
the U.S. government over the Obama administration's sanctions in
December 2016, or whether he had asked the Russians not to "escalate"
the matter and to keep their response "reciprocal." (Trump, at the time,
publicly said he wanted the U.S. to "move on" and not engage in a
bitter dispute with Russia.)
Flynn -- who
sold his home
in Virginia this year as his legal bills mounted -- declared in his
guilty plea nearly 11 months later that his comments on the issue were a
knowing lie to the FBI agents.
"It wasn't, 'Don't do anything,'"
Flynn told the agents when they asked him if he had requested that the
Russian ambassador not retaliate against the U.S., according to the 302.
Flynn intimated that the U.S. government's harsh sanctions came as a
"total surprise" to him, the document states.
Separately, agents
asked Flynn whether Kislyak had promised that Russia would "modulate"
its response to the sanctions, which were imposed by the Obama
administration in its final days in power in response to Russian
election meddling.
TOP REPUBLICAN PREDICTS FLYNN GUILTY PLEA WILL BE TOSSED, CITING FBI 'MISCONDUCT'
"Flynn
stated it was possible that he talked to Kislyak on the issue," the 302
stated, "but if he did, he did not remember doing so. Flynn stated he
was attempting to start a good relationship with Kislyak moving
forward."
The 302 continued: "Flynn remembered making four to five
calls that day about this issue, but that the Dominican Republic [where
he was vacationing] was a difficult place to make a call as he kept
having connectivity issues. Flynn reflected and stated that he did not
think he would have had a conversation with Kislyak about the matter, as
he did not know the expulsions [of 35 Russian diplomats from the
U.S. as part of the Obama administration's sanctions] were coming."
An
entire paragraph of the 302 concerning a "closed-door meeting" between
Flynn and Kislyak after the presidential election was redacted.
Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak, at right, meets with President
Trump and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. The May 10, 2017
meeting took place the same day Trump fired James Comey as FBI Director.
Trump was widely criticized during the meeting for revealing
information to the Russians about intelligence obtained from Israel
about an ISIS terror plot involving laptop bombs. Although the president
has the authority to disclose classified information, critics charged
the move was reckless and endangered Israeli sources. (AP)
The document concluded by noting that "Flynn stated
he did not have a long drawn out discussion with Kislyak where he would
have asked him to 'don't do something.'"
Flynn, in fact, had asked
Kislyak to "refrain from escalating the situation in response to
sanctions that the United States had imposed on Russia that same day,"
according to prosecutors, who said Kislyak "had chosen to moderate its
response to those sanctions as a result of his request."
Flynn
also denied to investigators that he had asked Russia to vote in any
particular way at the United Nations, saying his only calls to countries
were requests for information as to how they planned to vote. But
prosecutors said that Flynn had sought to convince Russia to veto a U.N.
Security Council resolution that condemned Israel’s settlements in the
West Bank. (The Obama
administration abstained in that vote, which Republicans characterized as a betrayal of a close U.S. ally.)
EX-SENATE INTEL STAFFER PLEADS GUILTY TO LYING TO FBI -- BUT DID HE LEAK FISA APPLICATION DAMAGING TO TRUMP?
Prosecutors addititonally
charged that a "very senior member” of the Trump transition team
directed Flynn to contact foreign governments including Russia over the
U.N. vote. The Associated Press reported the “very senior” official was
Trump son-in-law Jared Kushner.
During the interview at the White
House, Flynn twice thanked agents for reminding him about his contacts
with Kislyak concerning the U.N. -- an apparent indication that he was
well aware that the FBI, as The Post reported, had listened to his
conversations. ("Yes, good reminder," he said at one point, according to
the 302.)
Special Counsel Robert Mueller filed the witness report
documenting FBI agents' fateful conversation with Flynn late
Monday, shortly after U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan issued an
order Monday requiring that prosecutors publicly turn over the document.
Sullivan
had ordered the special counsel to turn over all government documents
and “memoranda” related to the questioning of Flynn last week, after
Flynn's attorneys,
in a bombshell filing,
claimed the FBI had discouraged him from bringing a lawyer to the White
House interview and intentionally decided not to warn him of the
consequences if he lied to agents.
Fired FBI Director James Comey
admitted last week
that the FBI's end-run around the White House Counsel -- which the FBI
usually involves in any of its interviews with senior White House
officials -- was not normal protocol, and that the FBI felt it could get
"away with" the tactic in the early days of the Trump administration.
COMEY: WE GOT 'AWAY WITH' FLYNN INTERVIEW, BROKE PROTOCOL
Last
Friday, Mueller met Sullivan’s deadline and provided some documents,
some of which were heavily redacted. One memorandum produced by Mueller
substantiated the claims by Flynn's lawyers that the FBI had cautioned
Flynn against involving a lawyer in the interview because doing so would
necessitate the Justice Department's involvement.
The memorandum,
written by then-Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe, also confirmed that
agents did not want to affect their "rapport" with Flynn by suggesting
he would be exposed to criminal liability if he lied.
"I explained
that I thought the quickest way to get this done was to have a
conversation between [Flynn] and the agents only," McCabe wrote. "I
further stated that if LTG Flynn wished to include anyone else in the
meeting, like the White House Counsel for instance, that I would need to
involve the Department of Justice. [General Flynn] stated that this
would not be necessary and agreed to meet with the agents without any
additional participants."
In this image made from a video taken on Dec. 10, 2015 and made
available on Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2017, US President Donald Trump's former
National Security Advisor Michael Flynn, right, shakes hands with
Russian President Vladimir Putin, in Moscow. (Ruptly via AP)
(The Associated Press)
However, the
special counsel did not publicly provide the January 302 witness report
that FBI policy dictated should have been written immediately after the
Flynn interview, leading to speculation as to whether one was drafted.
Sullivan's
order on Monday stated that Mueller's team had made confidential
arguments under seal as to redactions it would need to make to the 302.
Sullivan ruled that the redactions were appropriate and that due
to "strong presumption in favor of public access to judicial records,"
the 302 could be made public Monday.
STRZOK'S PHONE COMPLETELY WIPED AFTER HE WAS FIRED BY MUELLER FOR ANTI-TRUMP BIAS
The Flynn 302 released Monday further claimed Flynn was advised about the "nature of the interview" before it began.
However,
the McCabe memorandum released Friday apparently showed that the FBI
nudged Flynn not to have an attorney present during the questioning. And
FBI agents deliberately did not instruct Flynn that any false
statements he made could constitute a crime, and decided not to
"confront" him directly about anything he said that contradicted their
knowledge of his wiretapped communications with Kislyak.
One of
the agents who conducted the Flynn interview, Peter Strzok, was fired
from the Russia probe in late July 2017 over his apparent anti-Trump
bias.
Other portions of the document described apparently routine calls between Flynn and Kislyak about other matters.
On Sunday, GOP Rep. Devin Nunes told
Fox News' "Sunday Morning Futures" it was likely Flynn pleaded guilty only because of overwhelming financial pressure and because "he was just out of money."
California Republican Rep. Darrell Issa, for his part, told
host Maria Bartiromo
that he "would not be surprised a bit if the conviction of Flynn is
overturned, because of the Justice Department and FBI's misconduct."
In
June, Freedom Caucus Chair Rep. Mark Meadows, R-N.C, charged that the
FBI may have "edited and changed" key witness reports in the Hillary
Clinton and Russia investigations. Meadows also raised the possibility
that the FBI misled the Department of Justice watchdog in an attempt to
hide the identities of FBI employees who were caught sending anti-Trump
messages along with Strzok.
Speaking separately to
"Fox News Sunday," Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani flatly charged that Flynn had been "railroaded" and "framed."
"What
they did to General Flynn should result in discipline," Giuliani told
host Chris Wallace. "They’re the ones who are violating the law.
Giuliani
acknowledged that Flynn had misled Pence regarding his conversations
with the then-Russian ambassador, but added, "that was a lie, but that’s
not a crime."