Hillary Clinton or her representatives have, on at least two occasions, declined to accept legal papers delivered in connection with Tulsi Gabbard’s lawsuit against her, Gabbard’s attorney claims. Gabbard, a Democratic congresswoman from Hawaii who is seeking the party's 2020 presidential
nomination, filed a $50 million lawsuit against Clinton last week over
the former secretary of state’s insinuation that Gabbard was a “Russian asset.” Brian
Dunne, an attorney representing Gabbard, told the New York Post that
Secret Service agents turned away a process server Tuesday when the
server tried to deliver the lawsuit to Clinton’s home in Chappaqua,
N.Y., north of New York City. Dunne
said the server was instructed instead to deliver the papers to the
Washington office of Clinton’s lawyer, David Kendall, but Kendall’s
firm, Williams & Connolly, also declined to accept the legal papers,
according to the Post. “I find it rather unbelievable that
Hillary Clinton is so intimidated by Tulsi Gabbard that she won’t accept
service of process,” Dunne told the newspaper. “But I guess here we are.”
“I
find it rather unbelievable that Hillary Clinton is so intimidated by
Tulsi Gabbard that she won’t accept service of process. But I guess here
we are.” — Brian Dunne, attorney for Tulsi Gabbard
Dunne told the paper his team is considering what steps to take next. During a Jan. 23 appearance on "Fox & Friends," Gabbard accused Clinton of using “smear tactics” against her in an attempt to suppress her freedom of speech. “I
have dedicated my entire adult life to serving our country,” said
Gabbard, 38, a member of the Hawaii Army National Guard who served in
Iraq before being elected to Congress in 2012, “and for Hillary Clinton
and her powerful allies to attempt to smear me and accuse me -- really
implying that I'm a traitor to the country that I love -- is something
that I cannot allow to go unchecked." Clinton had said in an October 2019 interview that one of the Democratic presidential candidates was “the favorite of the Russians” and was being groomed as a third-party candidate for the 2020 general election in November. Clinton
never mentioned Gabbard by name, but when asked to confirm whether the
former first lady was referring to Gabbard, Clinton spokesman Nick
Merrill responded, “If the nesting doll fits … ” a reference to popular
Russian dolls. The remarks from Clinton drew immediate pushback from Gabbard on Oct. 18. “Great!
Thank you @HillaryClinton. You, the queen of warmongers, embodiment of
corruption, and the personification of the rot that has sickened the
Democratic Party for so long, have finally come out from behind the
curtain. From the day I announced my candidacy, there has been a …
concerted campaign to destroy my reputation. We wondered who was behind
it and why. Now we know – it was always you, through your proxies and …
powerful allies in the corporate media and war machine, afraid of the
threat I pose. It’s now clear that this primary is between you and me.
Don’t cowardly hide behind your proxies. Join the race directly. Gabbard’s
camp announced the lawsuit soon after the congresswoman’s Jan. 21
remarks, in which she criticized Clinton for claiming about Sen. Bernie
Sanders that “nobody likes him” and that “he got nothing done” as a
lawmaker. “It’s
time to grow up, you know? This isn’t high school,” Gabbard told
WMUR-TV in Manchester, N.H., referring to the Clinton comments. Gabbard
had supported Sanders in the 2016 race, and visited a Sanders campaign
office in Plymouth, N.H., earlier this week in what was being viewed as a
sign of dealmaking among Democratic candidates as the Iowa caucuses and
New Hampshire primary draw closer, The Washington Post reported. Fox News’ Julia Musto contributed to this story.
Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz, a member of President’s Trump's impeachment defense team, argued Wednesday that former Vice President Joe Biden’s
presidential candidacy justifies the president wanting to investigate
his son Hunter's involvement with a Ukrainian oil company. “The
fact that he’s announced his candidacy is a very good reason for upping
the interest in his son,” Dershowitz said, adding that the House
managers would agree that Trump running for re-election is the only
reason it could be an impeachable offense. Dershowitz asserted
that, hypothetically, if Trump wanted Hunter Biden investigated for
alleged corruption in his second term it wouldn't be impeachable. “The
difference, the House managers would make, is whether he’s in his first
term or his second term, whether he’s running for re-election or not
running for re-election," he said. "If he’s running for re-election
suddenly that turns it into an impeachable offense." Dershowitz
added that even if there was a quid pro quo by withholding $391 million
in military aid to Ukraine it wouldn’t matter because “if a president
does something which he believes will help him get elected in the public
interest, that cannot be the kind of quid pro quo that results in
impeachment.” He suggested Trump’s alleged request for
investigations during the July phone call with Ukrainian
President Volodymyr Zelensky was a “mixed motive,” meaning Trump
believed it would benefit both the country and incidentally himself. The
House managers have argued that Trump abused his power in asking
Ukraine to meddle in a U.S. election by investigating the son of his
political rival. "If you say you can’t hold a president
accountable in an election year where they are trying to cheat in that
election, then you are giving them carte blanche,” House manager Adam
Schiff responded. “So all quid pro quos are not the same. Some are
legitimate, and some are corrupt and you don’t need to be a mind reader
to figure out which is which.” Democrats
have also said that if Trump was legitimately concerned about
corruption involving Hunter Biden, he should have called for the Justice
Department to launch an official investigation.
Gov. Kay Ivey warned Alabamans on Wednesday that they can expect to see her with one of her arms in a sling following a Tuesday night fall. The governor said in a statement that she expects no disruption of her work schedule after tripping over her dog Missy and fracturing one of her shoulders, Birmingham's FOX6 reported. “Alabama’s
First Dog Missy is such a fun and active friend to have at home, and
she is fiercely protective,” Ivey wrote. “Last night, she
unintentionally tripped me up, and I hit my shoulder. You’ll see me in a
sling, but this won’t slow me down a bit! I’ll keep you posted on the
recovery, but most importantly, Missy is also doing just fine!” It wasn’t clear from the statement or from local news reports whether the governor’s left or right shoulder was injured. The
governor is expected to deliver the annual State of the State address
next Tuesday, FOX6 reported. On Wednesday, Ivey congratulated President
Trump after he signed the USMCA trade agreement. "What an exciting
day for our country as @POTUS officially signs #USMCA!" the governor
wrote. "Alabama is grateful for the hard work & leadership of
@realDonaldTrump & all involved for bringing this monumental deal to
fruition. Thank you for supporting the American people!" Ivey,
75, a Republican, became Alabama’s governor in April 2017 following the
resignation of her predecessor, Robert Bentley. She was then elected
outright in November 2018.
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey speaks to the media in Montgomery, Ala., Nov. 17, 2017. (Associated Press)
Earlier
this month Ivey announced she had received a positive report from her
doctor following radiation treatment for a cancerous spot found on one
of her lungs, according to AL.com. In November 2018, Ivey’s 14-year-old Chow mix, named Bear, died after a struggle with some health issues, AL.com reported. Ivey had adopted that dog from a local veterinarian after it was struck by a car, the report said.